How High Can the Hornets Fly?

Alessio Dionisi

Optimism is usually in plentiful supply during pre-season, but that is not really the case at Watford this summer. Yet another managerial change, another squad rebuild and another promise of a fresh start have done little to convince a fanbase that has grown increasingly frustrated with the club’s ownership.

Four years have now passed since relegation from the Premier League, yet rather than building towards a return, the Hornets have steadily drifted backwards. Finishes of 11th, 15th, 14th and 16th tell their own story, while last season ended in disastrous fashion with five straight defeats and an aggregate score of 16-1.

New Manager, Familiar Questions

Alessio Dionisi arrives with considerably more managerial experience than some of Watford’s recent appointments, but his CV does not guarantee success. His most recent spell ended after winning just five of his 22 matches before being dismissed by Empoli. Prior to that, he underachieved with Palermo, guiding one of Serie B’s strongest and best-funded squads to an eighth-place finish.

The Italian also faces the challenge of adapting to English football for the first time. While Dionisi has been improving his English and reports say training is conducted in the language, communication is only one part of the adjustment. The Championship is relentless, both physically and mentally, and plenty of experienced coaches have found it difficult to master.

Sporting director Gian Luca Nani has spoken positively about the impact Dionisi has made since arriving, claiming senior players have noticed a much-improved atmosphere around London Colney after morale hit rock bottom at the end of last season. Nani has also praised the new coaching staff, which includes analyst Luca Vigiani and fitness coach Nicolas Maidana, describing it as one of the strongest setups Watford have assembled in recent years.

Those comments are encouraging, but supporters have heard similar messages before, so you can take very little from them.

Don’t Read Too Much into Pre-Season


A 2-1 defeat to Boreham Wood to begin pre-season may have caused some concern, while a comfortable victory over Hansa Rostock and a narrow defeat against Fiorentina offered more encouragement. However, pre-season results rarely provide a reliable guide to what follows when the actual season kicks off.

There has been one genuine positive from pre-season so far though, this being the return of Rocco Vata. The 21-year-old made his first appearance since January against Fiorentina and almost marked his comeback with an assist after creating a chance for Luca Kjerrumgaard. Considering how much attacking quality Watford lacked at times last season, having Vata available again could prove one of the club’s biggest boosts.

Recruitment Still Revolves Around Udinese

Luca Kjerrumgaard
Luca Kjerrumgaard (Timmy96 | Wikipedia)

There was little doubt Watford needed reinforcements this summer, and the club has strengthened in several areas with five new signings, while also making Kjerrumgaard’s loan move permanent.

Player From Position Fee
Martin Payero Udinese CM Undisclosed
Federico Ravaglia Bologna GK Undisclosed
Luca Kjerrumgaard Udinese ST Undisclosed
Iker Bravo Udinese ST Undisclosed
Omar Traore Udinese RB Undisclosed
Jordan Zemura Udinese LB Loan

The issue is that five of the six arrivals have come directly from sister club Udinese, with Ravaglia the only signing recruited from elsewhere. That does not necessarily make them bad signings, but relying so heavily on one source is an inherently restrictive recruitment strategy. Rather than searching the wider market for the best available options, Watford continue to put most of their faith in players from their sister club, an approach that many supporters have grown increasingly frustrated with. It hasn’t worked before and seems unlikely to do so now, with a feeling that Watford’s interests are not at the heart of the recruitment policy.

Despite the business completed so far, centre-back remains one position that has not been addressed. Bringing in another defender before the window closes would leave the squad looking far more complete ahead of the new season.

What Would Count as Progress?

Watford FC celebrating
Jon Candy | Flickr

Expectations this season should remain realistic. The Championship is one of the most competitive leagues in Europe, and significant improvement rarely happens overnight. Watford’s recent league finishes suggest they are much closer to mid-table than they are to challenging for automatic promotion.

The expansion of the play-offs to include teams finishing between third and eighth does at least offer a slightly bigger target. If Dionisi can produce the consistency Watford have lacked since relegation, an outside push for the top eight is not impossible. However, it would require a level of stability the club has struggled to achieve for several years.

A top-half finish would probably represent a successful campaign. It may not satisfy supporters dreaming of a quick return to the Premier League, but it would at least demonstrate clear progress after finishing 16th last season and provide something to build on.

The Bookmakers’ Verdict

The bookmakers broadly share this assessment. Watford are around 3/1 to finish inside the top eight, and priced 2/1 to finish in the top half. Based on these odds, anything north of 13th place would represent an overachievement for the Hornets.

While this might not fill supporters with optimism, the bookmakers are pricing Watford at 6/1 to be relegated. That suggests there is at least an expectation that the Hornets should avoid being dragged into a relegation battle, even if a promotion push appears unlikely. Time will tell!