Hornets Stumble in Cup and League But Play-Off Hopes Remain Alive

Yellow and black football

After a convincing 3-0 win over Birmingham City on New Year’s Day, Watford climbed to fourth in the Championship table. That victory marked a fourth consecutive league win and had Hornets supporters wondering just how long the impressive run could last.

The answer came swiftly as Watford have followed that high point with a run of three winless games. While these results have been a setback, they have not derailed Watford’s season by any means. The Hornets’ play-off hopes remain very much alive, as we will explore on this page.

Recent Defeats of Little Concern

Two defeats and a disappointing draw in quick succession can sometimes trigger panic, but there is little reason for Watford fans to feel alarmed.

Bristol City

Bristol City logoThe first loss came in the FA Cup, where Watford were deservedly beaten 5-1 away at Bristol City. The scoreline and nature of the defeat look worrying, but Javi Gracia made eight changes to the side that had comfortably beaten Birmingham nine days earlier.

While the Spaniard would have expected more from his second-string team, poor performances following heavy rotation are a frequent FA Cup sight. This is particularly true for sides that have bigger priorities, such as a possible promotion. So, as far as excuses go, making wholesale changes is a reasonable one, even if the manner of the defeat was disappointing.

Millwall

Millwall logoThe league defeat to Millwall, on the other hand, was harder to stomach. Facing a fellow promotion contender at Vicarage Road, Watford delivered a poor first-half performance. Millwall dominated proceedings and restricted the hosts to very little attacking threat. In fact, Watford did not register a shot on target until first-half injury time, highlighting just how flat their display was.

The hosts responded positively, though, looking more like their usual selves following the restart. However, it was Millwall who struck first, and they added a second goal 12 minutes later to seal the points. It was a fair result in the end, but losing to one of the division’s strongest sides, especially after improving in the second half, is far from a disaster.

Portsmouth

Portsmouth logoMore recently was the midweek draw at home to struggling Portsmouth. This is a fixture a play-off hopeful ought to be winning, but the Hornets never really got going. Their defence was largely solid, bar the mistake by Jeremy Ngakia that let Portsmouth score, but their attack was unusually flat. Still, bad games can happen, and Pompey, despite their lowly league position, are unbeaten in six league matches.

Upcoming Fixtures


What any team wants after a few poor results is a great opportunity to rebuild momentum, and Watford appear to have exactly that. There is rarely such a thing as an easy game in the Championship, but the Hornets now face a couple of fixtures against sides in the lower half of the table.

Date Opponent
24th January 2026 Blackburn (A)
31st January 2026 Swansea (H)

A Fiercely Competitive Battle

While Watford deserve to be considered serious play-off hopefuls, the level of competition cannot be overstated. The Championship table remains incredibly tight, and it is likely the play-off spaces will be hotly contested deep into the season.

The battle is particularly intense around the final play-off spot, with six teams within three points of sixth-placed Preston. A small patch of bad form at this stage will inevitably see a team slide down the table.

Position Team Games Played Points
5th Millwall 28 46
6th Preston 28 43
7th Watford 27 42
8th Stoke 28 41
9th Wrexham 28 41
10th Derby 28 41
11th Bristol City 28 40
12th QPR 28 40

One key advantage Watford currently hold is that they have a game in hand. Winning this extra match, or even drawing it, would see Watford return to the all-important top six.

The only real question mark still hanging over the Hornets is how they will cope with the departure of Max Alleyen, who was recalled by parent club Manchester City. Watford have failed to win since he left Vicarage Road, and the youngster leaves a significant gap in the heart of defence that will need filling by someone of similar quality.

Is There Hope of Automatic Promotion?

Watford looking happy
Cosmin Iftode | Shutterstock

Play-offs will be the main goal for Gracia’s side this season, and that in itself would be a fantastic achievement given the Hornets have finished 14th and 15th the previous two years. However, could they dream even bigger? Automatic promotion currently sits ten points away, with Watford having a game in hand. If they were to win this, it would be a seven-point gap with 19 games to play.

While this is not an insurmountable margin, one issue is the sheer number of teams in the way. Even if second-place Middlesbrough suffer a slump, someone like Ipswich or Hull will simply take their place. There is also little to suggest that Watford are top-two material when looking at their attacking or defensive output. Plus, they are unlikely to benefit from big upgrades in the January transfer window, which could help them reach a higher level.