Watford Dismiss Pezzolano and Bring Back Gracia for Second Spell

Javi Gracia

The managerial merry-go-round continues at Watford, this time with Paulo Pezzolano booted out and former manager Javi Gracia brought back in. The club officially announced the news on 9th October, with both the exit and arrival happening at the same time, suggesting it was far from a ‘spur of the moment’ decision.

In this article, we will look at why Pezzolano was axed after just 10 games and whether the re-appointment of Gracia is likely to trigger a positive response at Vicarage Road.

Pezzolano’s Short-Lived Spell

Paulo Pezzolano
Paulo Pezzolano (Christian Bertrand | Shutterstock)

While 10 matches in charge is not a lot, this is about as long as the Pozzo regime tends to give managers they do not like these days. Both Chris Wilder and Rob Edwards only made it to 11 matches before being fired, so a swift exit like this is not particularly unheard of. Ten matches does, however, set the record for the shortest stay of any Watford manager since Billy McKinlay’s two-game stint in 2014.

Matches Wins Draws Losses Win %
10 3 3 4 30

While a win percentage of 30% is certainly nothing to shout about, it is better than what five of the last seven Watford managers have managed. The only two exceptions are Tom Cleverley (33.9%) and Slaven Bilic (38.5%).

To outsiders, this sacking may look like a fairly strange one, even for a club as trigger-happy as Watford. After all, the Hertfordshire side sit 11th in the Championship table, just three points from the play-offs. This is a fairly reasonable start by all accounts, and perhaps more importantly, results were improving. Pezzolano collected seven points from the last nine available, which is far from the kind of form that usually gets managers sacked.

Despite this, the decision to part ways with Pezzolano is not an unpopular one, with most of the Hornets’ faithful in favour of the early decision. Fans cite reasons such as underwhelming performances, strange team selections, falling out with players and a prickly personality for the justified sacking. The language barrier was also a problem, with the Uruguayan not having a firm grasp of English and requiring a translator for more complex instructions/speeches.

So, in this instance, it seems as though the initial appointment was simply a mistake in the first place and was very unlikely to work out. In such cases, there is little point in giving a manager time if they do not seem like a good fit, just for the sake of being more patient. Indeed, by firing him so early into the new campaign, Watford are still firmly in a position to fight for the play-off places with their new manager, Javi Gracia.

How Will the Squad React to Gracia?

It is fair to suggest that most of the Watford squad will enjoy playing under Gracia more than they did under the disciplinarian Pezzolano. According to reports, Pezzolano had all the players on strict diets and would constantly change training schedules with little notice based on what he thought was best. Players stepping out of line were often punished or excluded, and this may have contributed to Nestory Irankunda’s substitution after just 35 minutes against Portsmouth.

There was also little consistency with Pezzolano, who was regularly chopping and changing his preferred starting line-up, often without any good reason. Some players grew frustrated at this as they felt they had done nothing to deserve being dropped from the team. There was also a sudden change in formation. The club practised 4-4-3 over the summer and began the season that way, only for Pezzolano to change to a back five following an opening day defeat to Charlton.

What to Expect with Gracia


With Gracia, Watford should enjoy more consistency and less of the hard-edged disciplinarian approach that defined Pezzolano’s brief reign. It does seem like Gracia, who is fondly remembered at Vicarage Road, was the man the club always wanted this season. He was approached about the vacant position in the summer but had to rule himself out as he was recovering from major hip surgery. Having had a chance to recover since then, the Spaniard was able to seize the opportunity to return to his former club.

As one of Watford’s most liked managers and the one who guided them to the 2019 FA Cup final, he will likely command a fair amount of respect from the players. It is also a decision that will get the fans on board and could help improve the mood around Vicarage Road. Even from game one, Pezzolano was not a popular figure, whereas Gracia will enjoy a very warm reception. He also has the benefit of a decent opening fixture, away to bottom of the table Sheffield United, which could help build some initial momentum.

Is Gracia the Right Man for the Job?

The Watford powers that be have ambitious targets for their managers and want someone who can at least be in the hunt for a promotion place. Even finishing in the play-offs, let alone one of the two automatic places, would represent a large overachievement for Gracia, though. Watford are trading at 8/1 with most bookmakers to secure a top six finish, a price which is higher than their relegation odds (6/1).

The bookies expect the usual lower mid-table finish from Watford this season, and Opta’s supercomputer does the same. Its current predicted table has the Hornets to finish in 17th place with a 15% chance of relegation and 7.5% chance of earning promotion via the play-offs. At this point, you have to ask what a successful season for Watford would even look like. Simply collecting more points than the 57 collected last year? Finishing in the top half?

While Gracia may be able to manage either, anyone expecting some sort of miracle may be disappointed. Watford have a young squad and joining mid-season is often a tough ask for any manager, especially one who will deploy a completely different system. A solid mid-table finish, with a view to pushing for promotion next year, would be a fair target in our view. Whether Gracia is afforded this amount of time remains to be seen, although he has been issued a two-year contract. Admittedly, this is not a huge statement of trust, but it is longer than the contract Pezzolano received.

Whether Gracia can oversee improvements, modest or major, is hard to say. Optimists will tell you he has a good record at Watford, and the state of the squad is better now than it has been in recent years. Pessimists will say the club has a poor record of picking managers, and reappointing a previous success story is far from a safe bet. When the club reappointed Quique Sanchez Flores, he ended up winning just two of his 12 games in charge before being fired.