If Watford are not careful, they could easily follow in the footsteps of fellow former Premier League side Stoke City, who have completely stagnated since relegation in 2018. The Potters have finished between 14th and 18th in every Championship season since dropping out of the top flight, showing zero sign of progress.
The worrying thing for Watford is that they are beginning to follow a very similar path. Since relegation from the Premier League in 2022, the Hornets have finished 11th, 15th, 14th and now, in the 2025/26 season, 16th. Their points totals also paint a picture of a team unable to improve, having earned 63, 56, 57 and 57 points in the respective seasons. The most frustrating aspect is that Watford have regularly shown promise. In each of the last four campaigns, they have either been in or around the play-off places by January.
Despite starting strongly enough, a massive crash has always followed. Looking at the final 19 league matches of each season highlights the issue clearly. Watford won just four of those games in 2022/23, three in 2023/24, four in 2024/25 and only three again in 2025/26. A pattern this consistent suggests there are deep problems at the club.
Whether it is poor squad depth, issues with injuries and/or fitness, or poor mentality, Watford have repeatedly failed to maintain the required standards across a full Championship campaign. To get them out of this rut, here is what needs to change at Vicarage Road.
Stick with a Manager

It is obvious to most fans and pundits that one of Watford’s biggest problems has been the constant managerial turnover. Stability becomes impossible when coaches are dismissed after every poor run of form. Managers need time to understand their players, implement ideas and build trust within the squad. Constant changes prevent the development of any long-term progression.
While some coaches may view the job as an easy payout, many talented managers will avoid a club where one bad month can cost them employment. There will always be someone willing to take the role, but Watford’s reputation for impatience likely reduces the pool of candidates compared to other Championship clubs of a similar size. Additionally, most coaches perform better when they feel trusted and supported rather than constantly under pressure.
There is also the financial aspect to consider. Paying off managers and their staff often does not come cheap, so this has been a significant expense for Watford, given their remarkable churn. The Hornets have gone through 11 managers since the end of the 2020/21 season and have made 22 permanent managerial appointments since 2014. At some point, the club hierarchy just needs to commit to a longer-term vision rather than constantly resetting.
Invest Better in the Squad
Watford have reportedly made close to £100 million in transfer profit over the last five seasons. While that has helped the club financially, it does not translate to progress on the pitch. The Hornets do not have the spending power of recently relegated Premier League clubs, but a smarter investment strategy could still make a huge difference. Too often, recruitment has not felt part of a clear strategy, backed by the head coach.
Their limited transfer activity in January 2026 was reportedly one of the reasons Javi Gracia decided to quit. He wanted experienced players capable of helping an injury-hit squad compete for the play-offs. Instead, the club brought in several young loan signings with little experience. Gracia initially turned down the opportunity to sign one of these (Saba Goglichidze), before presumably realising he was not going to get anyone better.
In a recent statement, Watford’s chairman and CEO pointed to the signing of 14 players in the summer and four more in January as proof of ambition. However, such statements have done little to convince supporters that this represents genuine ambition. The club relied heavily on loans, free transfers and low-cost gambles. This “see what sticks” approach results in many new recruits getting very little time on the pitch (seven loanees registered under 1,000 minutes).
Watford Need a Reliable Goalscorer

Another major issue for Watford has been the lack of a reliable striker capable of consistently scoring goals across a full Championship season. No Watford player has scored 15 league goals in a season since Odion Ighalo managed the feat during the 2015/16 campaign, nor has anyone come close.
In a demanding 46-game Championship season, having a striker capable of scoring 15+ goals, or close to it, can completely change a club’s fortunes. If the Hornets are serious about returning to the Premier League, signing a proven goalscorer must become a priority. Without one, another season of inconsistency and mid-table frustration feels likely.
Conclusion
Four straight seasons of mid-table finishes and repeated second-half collapses suggest deep-rooted issues at Vicarage Road that need addressing. With parachute payments now ceased, Watford are in increased danger of being stuck in a rut if they do not get their approach to managers and player recruitment right.
Even if it is at the cost of some short-term pain, the Hornets must finally commit to a clear long-term plan. That means sticking with a manager, adding leaders to the squad and finding the reliable goalscorer they have lacked for nearly a decade.
